Obama’s ‘green’ battery plants cause more pollution

July 19, 2010 05:29

A 2009 study by Carnegie Mellon University comparing the effectiveness of vehicles powered by large plug-in batteries to those powered by small plug-in batteries and conventional hybrid engines found that the largest battery tested, which offered a range of 60 miles per charge, actually produced 10% more greenhouse gases than a battery with a range of only 7 miles when regular recharging was possible, as would be expected with urban driving.

By Joe Tauke – The Daily Caller

President Obama visited Holland, Michigan on Thursday to celebrate a potential success story for both the stimulus package and his auto bailout — the groundbreaking of a factory that will produce the lithium-ion batteries necessary to power thousands of new green vehicles built by Ford and General Motors.

So why does the world’s most successful maker of eco-friendly cars believe that Detroit is once again on its way to peddling products that Americans don’t want to buy?

Toyota Motor Corp., which in 2009 sold more hybrid vehicles in the U.S. than all other auto manufacturers combined, has spent more than a decade developing its own lithium-ion technology. Yet, where Detroit and apparently the Obama administration see a market for nearly-emissionless automobiles, Toyota sees demand for cheaper, low-emissions products. Its first lithium-ion electric vehicle, a version of the Prius, will only have an average range of 13 miles per charge before the standard hybrid engine takes over. GM and Ford are both preparing to launch vehicles designed to rely mostly upon massive batteries that boast an average range of over 30 miles per charge.

The range disparity is no accident on Toyota’s part.

“Consumers have to pay a premium for plug-in capability,” said John Hanson, Toyota’s National Manager of Environmental, Safety, and Quality Communications, in an interview with The Daily Caller. “If we’re trying to create mainstream acceptability, cost is a huge factor, and small batteries are the way to go.”

In other words, the stimulus-sponsored push for rangy electric cars is useless without customers. Dr. Menahem Anderman, president of Advanced Automotive Batteries, explained via email that the White House is getting its own way by ignoring economic reality.

“Rushing to build multiple plug-in battery plants is misguided,” Anderman wrote. “Neither the plug-in battery technology nor the plug-in market are proven and both carry significant risks.”


Help Make A Difference By Sharing These Articles On Facebook, Twitter And Elsewhere:

Interested In Further Reading? Click Here